What is the criteria for cc in AE section?What exactly is the criteria used in reviewing and rewarding the AE responses? I am sorry if I am expressing doubts on editors, but the reason for my complaint is why do we see differential rewards for similar responses? I had also pointed this out before. My point is in connection with THIS LINK . I don't see much of a difference in two responses, o's is there? Can anyone point out the changes please?
One more interesting point - whenever this kind of a question comes up , I see the similar response with exact words but only a few changes in numbers! Is this what we call innovative? What about this who explain the details in a little more detail instead of using cliché words repeatedly? I am sorry once again for pointing fingers at the editors, but I guess I am entitled to voice my views.